What Makes Your Marriage Invalid – and How to Know if Annulment Is Right for You
Annulment is a rare remedy compared to divorce. However, if the right conditions apply, it allows a court to declare that the marriage was never valid from the start.
Unlike divorce, which ends a legally valid marriage, an annulment means the marriage is treated as though it never legally existed. Here, we explore what annulment is, how it differs from divorce, common legal grounds for an annulment, and how to decide if you are entitled to an annulment and if it is the right path for you.
What is an Annulment?
An annulment is a legal process that declares a marriage void, meaning that in the eyes of the law, the marriage never legally existed. Where divorce ends a legally valid marriage, an annulment erases it from a legal standpoint, as if the marriage never happened in the first place.
This distinction is important because an annulment doesn’t “end” a relationship the way a divorce does. Instead, it states that the relationship was never legally valid to begin with due to a defect that existed at the time of the marriage ceremony, or the commencement of the marriage. The defect could involve issues such as fraud, coercion, incapacity, or one spouse already being married to someone else, which is the most common reason for annulment. In other words, the law views the marriage as void (never legally recognized) or voidable (valid until a court declares otherwise.)
With annulment:
- The marriage record is legally erased as though the marriage never existed.
- Each party returns to the legal status of ”single” rather than “divorced.”
- Property rights, financial obligations, and spousal support will be treated differently than in divorce.
- However, children born during the marriage remain legitimate, and both parents continue to have rights and responsibilities such as custody and child support.
Because annulment essentially rewinds the clock, it is only available under limited circumstances and usually requires specific grounds as defined by your state’s law.
Schedule your free meeting with our team today to see if our Lawyers can help you.
How Annulment Differs from Divorce
At first glance, annulment and divorce may seem like two ways to end a marriage, but they differ in their purpose, process, and outcome.
| Aspect | Annulment | Divorce |
|---|---|---|
| Legal effect | Declares the marriage never legally existed | Legally ends a valid marriage |
| Reason required | Must prove a legal defect existed at the time of the marriage | Based on fault or no-fault grounds |
| Availability | Limited and rare; must meet strict criteria | Available for all valid marriages |
| Property and support rights | Often limited or dependent on “putative spouse” laws | Fully governed by divorce statutes |
| Children | Children remain legitimate; custody and support still apply | Same treatment; child legitimacy is unaffected |
| Religious considerations | Sometimes sought for faith-based reasons | Civil proceeding only; no religious effect |
In short, divorce dissolves a legal union, while annulment establishes that a valid union never existed. Divorce assumes the marriage met all legal requirements and later broke down. Annulment assumes the marriage was defective from the start.
Because annulments carry unique implications for property, benefits, and even emotional closure, it’s important to speak with an experienced family law attorney to confirm whether your situation meets your state’s annulment requirements or whether divorce is the more practical solution.
The Legal Effect of an Annulment
Not every marriage qualifies for annulment. Because annulment laws are designed for rare circumstances, the courts limit them to situations where something fundamental was wrong from the start – something that made the marriage invalid in the eyes of the law.
Every state defines these grounds a little differently, but most fall into two main categories: void marriages and voidable marriages.
A void marriage is one that could never be valid under any circumstances. It’s considered null from the moment it began, such as when one spouse was already legally married to someone else. A voidable marriage, on the other hand, starts out valid but can be annulled if one spouse asks the court to declare it invalid. These are typically cases involving fraud, duress, or incapacity – situations where one party’s consent wasn’t freely or fully given.
Fraud and Misrepresentation
Fraud is one of the most common grounds for annulment. It happens when one spouse lies about or hides something so significant that the other spouse would not have agreed to marry had they known the truth. Examples might include concealing a previous marriage, hiding an inability to have children, being a prostitute, or marrying solely for immigration purposes. Fraud must go to the heart of the marriage, not just a minor disagreement or a personality issue that surfaced later.
Duress or Lack of Consent
A marriage entered into under threat, pressure, or force is not valid. If one spouse only agreed to marry because they were afraid of the consequences of saying no, the marriage may be annulled for duress, which is frequently seen in immigration issues. Similarly, a marriage may be invalid if a person lacked the mental or physical ability to give genuine consent – for example, if they were under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time of the ceremony, or suffered from a mental incapacity that prevented them from understanding the nature of the marriage contract.
Underage Marriage
In every state, the law sets a minimum age to marry, and some require parental or judicial consent for minors. If one or both spouses were underage and those consent requirements weren’t met, the marriage can often be annulled. While some underage marriages can later be “ratified” once the individuals reach legal age, others remain voidable if a parent or guardian challenges the validity of the marriage.
Bigamy or Incest
Certain relationships are considered void from the start. If one spouse was already legally married to someone else, this is bigamy and the second marriage cannot stand. Similarly, marriages between close relatives, such as siblings, parents and children, or first cousins in some states, are considered incestuous and legally void.
Incapacity or Impotence
An annulment may also be granted when one spouse is physically unable to consummate the marriage, and the condition is permanent, incurable, and unknown to the other spouse before the wedding. Courts view the ability to engage in marital relations as a central part of the marriage contract; therefore, concealing such a condition can justify an annulment.
In short, annulment isn’t about a marriage that went wrong. It’s about a marriage that should never have been recognized in the first place.
If one of these conditions existed at the time of your marriage, you may be eligible to petition the court for an annulment. Because the laws vary widely by state, it’s important to speak with a family law attorney who is familiar with your state’s statutes.
Click to contact our family lawyers today
Religious Annulments vs. Civil Annulments
It’s important to understand that a religious annulment and a civil annulment are not the same thing – and they have very different purposes.
A civil annulment is granted by a state court and deals strictly with legal status. It determines whether a marriage was valid under the law, which affects issues like property rights, taxes, child custody, and support. Once a civil annulment is granted, it’s as though the marriage never legally existed.
A religious annulment, on the other hand, is granted by a church or other faith authority, not by the state. It does not change your legal marital status. Instead, it addresses whether the marriage met the requirements of that faith’s religious doctrine. A religious annulment only affects the spouses’ standing within the church; however, the state will still consider them legally married unless they also undergo the civil annulment or divorce process. Likewise, if spouses receive a civil annulment, it has no automatic effect on their religious status.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today
How to Get an Annulment in Your State
If you believe your marriage may qualify for annulment, the process begins much like a divorce, but with a different goal and a narrower legal foundation. Because annulments challenge the very validity of the marriage itself, courts scrutinize these cases closely. Every state has its own laws and procedures, but the general steps follow a similar pattern.
- The first step is determining whether you have a legitimate legal basis for annulment. This means understanding your state’s statutes to confirm your situation meets one of the recognized grounds.
- Once eligibility is established, your attorney will begin to gather the facts of your situation. In some states, certain grounds come with time limits.
- You or your attorney will file a petition for annulment with the family court in your county. This document will explain your grounds and ask the court to declare your marriage null and void.
- Just like a divorce, the other spouse must be formally served with the paperwork and given a chance to respond.
- If both parties agree that the marriage was invalid, the process can move quickly; if one contests the claim, the case may require hearings, evidence, and witness testimony.
- After reviewing the evidence, the court may schedule a hearing where a judge will determine whether the facts meet your state’s legal standard for annulment. If the judge agrees, they will issue a Decree of Annulment (sometimes called a Judgment of Nullity), officially declaring the marriage void. In legal terms, this means you were never married at all.
- Once the decree is entered, both individuals return to single legal status, free to remarry. Marital history will reflect no valid prior marriage.
Evidence plays a central role in annulment cases. Courts expect proof that supports the reason for invalidating the marriage, such as medical documentation, records of a prior undissolved marriage, or communications showing fraud or misrepresentation. Unlike divorce, which can proceed on no-fault grounds, annulments require clear and convincing evidence that a defect existed at the time of the wedding.
Because annulment laws vary so widely, what qualifies in one state may not qualify in another. Working with a local family law attorney ensures that the petition is filed correctly, supported by evidence, and timed within any statutory deadlines.
Practical Concerns of Annulment
Even though an annulled marriage is treated as if it never existed, some practical matters still need resolution.
- Property and debt division – Because the marriage is treated as never valid, some of the typical divorce rules may not apply. Many states only allow property division or support if one spouse qualifies as a “putative spouse,” or the spouse who acted in good faith, believing the marriage was valid.
- Child support and/or custody – the annulment does not automatically relieve parental obligations. Children born of the marriage remain legitimate, and parental rights and responsibilities still apply.
- Name change, insurance, pensions, and other benefits – Many of these practical issues may still need to be addressed even though the marriage has been annulled.
Is Annulment the Right Choice for You?
For many, the idea of annulment somehow feels cleaner and simpler than divorce. But in reality, an annulment isn’t faster or easier. In fact, it can be far more complex, because the court must determine that a legal defect existed at the very start of the marriage, not simply that the relationship has failed.
Another important consideration is timing. Many states impose strict deadlines on annulment claims, especially when the grounds are based on fraud or misrepresentation. Waiting too long to act, or continuing to live together after discovering the issue, can sometimes bar you from seeking an annulment at all. Divorce, by contract, generally has no such limitation.
It’s also important to separate the emotional and spiritual aspects from the legal ones. While some individuals pursue annulment for religious reasons, it’s essential to understand that a civil annulment only affects legal status, not religious standing.
Whether annulment is the right choice depends on your circumstances and your goals. The key question is whether your marriage was legally valid to begin with. If something prevented valid consent or made the marriage unlawful, then an annulment might make sense. But if the marriage was valid and you’re simply no longer compatible, then divorce will be the appropriate path.
Getting Legal Guidance
Annulments occupy a unique corner of family law. For some, it offers the opportunity to correct a marriage that was never valid under the law. For others, it provides closure and peace of mind after discovering deception or coercion. Yet because annulments are so narrowly defined and differ from state to state, the process can be confusing without experienced legal guidance.
If you believe your marriage may qualify for an annulment, or if you want to understand if it’s a possible option for your situation, the family law attorneys at Melone Hatley, P.C. have extensive experience navigating these complex cases. We will listen to your story, review your circumstances, and help you take the next step, whether that is an annulment or divorce. Call us at 800-479-8124 or schedule a free consultation with one of our Client Services Coordinators through our website contact form.
Helpful references:
- Virginia annulment and marriage validity provisions
- Texas annulment requirements (TexasLawHelp)
- South Carolina annulment and family law statutes
- Florida annulment discussion (University of Florida Law Review)
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today.
