When a marriage hits a rough patch, spouses often face agonizing decisions. Is it just a difficult time they’ll be able to overcome, or is it the end of the relationship?
For couples who aren’t sure which way it will go, a trial separation can offer a middle ground, allowing them to take time apart to consider the next steps. Separation gives both parties some much-needed space to think about what they want for the future of their relationship, whether it’s rededication to making things better or divorce. However, while trial separation can provide some emotional and logistical breathing room, it can also carry certain legal and financial risks.
At Melone Hatley, P.C., our experienced family law attorneys understand the emotional weight of deciding whether to stay or go. If you’re considering stepping away from your marriage to gain some perspective, we can help you understand both the perks (and risks) of doing so, so you can make an educated decision.
The Upside of Getting Space: Why Couples Often Separate
For couples going through a difficult time in their marriage, a trial separation can feel like hitting the pause button and taking a step back. Done carefully and thoughtfully, it can be valuable for several reasons.
- It can provide some clarity and perspective. Absence really can make the heart grow fonder – or it can make it clear that spouses are happier apart. Physical distance can allow couples time to reflect without the day-to-day friction that can keep them in conflict and cloud good judgment.
- It can reduce conflict. Sometimes, living under the same roof can exacerbate underlying conflicts. Taking time apart can reduce that constant tension and allow each spouse to experience the relationship from a more objective perspective.
- It can allow time for growth and important conversations. Couples often use this time to focus on counseling or personal goals. Spouses usually learn more about their own needs outside the pressure of their marriage.
- It can provide a “soft landing.” A trial separation affords a way to transition out of the marriage slowly if divorce seems inevitable and test how life might look post-marriage.
- It also allows space for marriage counseling, a recommitment to the relationship, and possible reconciliation when both partners are ready to work together.
In short, a trial separation can offer spouses emotional and physical distance, allowing them to gain perspective and possibly reunite as a happier couple. For others, it provides a smoother transition toward divorce. Either way, when couples approach separation with clear intentions and open communication, it can ensure their time apart is constructive, not chaotic.
Schedule your free meeting with our team today to see if our Lawyers can help you.
The Fine Print: The Risks of a Trial Separation
While a trial separation can offer emotional and physical relief from the stresses of a marriage in decline, it doesn’t come without risks. Couples often assume that a trial separation is an informal, consequence-free break from the stresses of marriage. But that assumption can be costly. Consider the following:
- You have no legal protection. In an informal separation, you are still married in the eyes of the law. You are still responsible and obligated to your spouse and the marriage until a final divorce decree is filed. Depending on the jurisdiction, any assets and debts acquired during your time apart are marital property and subject to division, regardless of who acquired them. One spouse could empty a joint bank account or relocate with the children without the other’s consent.
- Who pays the bills? While you’re separated, bills still need to be paid, and property maintained. Who stays in the house? How will you share time with your children? Will one spouse pay child or spousal support? And what happens if that spouse doesn’t comply with informal or verbal promises?
- What are the expectations around your separation? Can you date? (Remember, you’re still married, and you could potentially be accused of adultery in a subsequent divorce proceeding.) At what point does separation merely delay an inevitable divorce?
- Have you considered the legal gray areas? In states like Virginia, South Carolina, Florida, and Texas, there is no formal recognition of legal separation. That means that separating without divorce offers no legal protections. Even in Virginia, where spouses must live “separate and apart” to be eligible for a no-fault divorce, there is no legal protection while spouses live apart.
While a trial separation can provide much-needed relief from conflict, it’s not without pitfalls. Without clear boundaries and legal safeguards, couples risk financial complications, misunderstandings, and unintended consequences. Taking the time to plan and communicate can make all the difference between a healing pause in the relationship and a messy unraveling.
What is a Separation Agreement and What Should Be Included in It?
One of the most important steps separating couples can take is to put a clear agreement in writing. While a trial separation may seem informal, it shouldn’t be left to chance legally. Without clearly defined expectations and responsibilities, even the friendliest and most well-meaning arrangements can result in legal and financial trouble. A separation agreement offers both spouses protection until they decide on the next step.
A separation agreement is a legal contract that outlines clear expectations and boundaries, defining the terms by which spouses will live apart.
- It should include who will live in the marital home and who will move out.
- If children are involved, the agreement should outline decision-making responsibilities, parenting schedules, and communication expectations.
- It should reflect who will pay the mortgage and who will cover health insurance or daycare costs.
- It should specify how ongoing expenses such as home maintenance and utility bills will be shared. Putting these terms in writing reduces the risk of misunderstandings and ensures both parties are on the same page.
Ultimately, a well-developed separation agreement is about protecting both spouses while providing the space they need to consider their next steps. A separation agreement can reduce conflict, avoid financial surprises, and maintain structure for the children until the next move is decided.
Click to contact our family lawyers today
Protecting Your Future While Taking Time Apart
Taking time apart shouldn’t mean losing control of your future. With the right planning and guidance, a trial separation can be a thoughtful step, whether you’re working toward a reconciliation or preparing for divorce. Protecting your rights and setting clear expectations ensures that your time apart is productive, rather than filled with more conflict.
At Melone Hatley, P.C., we work with couples at every stage of separation and divorce, from informal trial periods to contested divorces. If you’re considering a trial separation, it’s essential to understand your responsibilities and the legal and financial implications of your decisions. Our experienced family law attorneys can help you structure an agreement that protects your future and your peace of mind. Call us today at (800) 479-8124 or contact us through our website contact form to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our Client Services Coordinators.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today.
