Practical Answers for Couples Dividing Property During Divorce
Divorce doesn’t just end a marriage – it divides the life a couple has built together. Among the most difficult decisions couples face is what happens to the marital home. Because laws differ and economic circumstances may change over time, understanding how property division works in general provides a foundation for protecting your financial stability, no matter where you live.
Schedule your free meeting with our team today to see if our Lawyers can help you.
Understanding Property Division During Divorce
Who gets the house after divorce? Divorce laws vary by state, but they all aim to ensure a fair division of marital property. The two main systems of property division are community property and equitable distribution.
Community property states presume that most assets acquired during marriage are owned equally by both spouses. In these states, property division typically begins with a 50/50 split, but specific circumstances may be considered to create a fairer division.
Equitable distribution states focus on fairness over equality. Courts weigh factors like income, financial need, and each spouse’s contributions to decide how to divide property in a just way.
When courts make property division determinations, they use one of these systems, depending on the jurisdiction. In other words, the legal framework for property division in your state sets the foundation for how marital assets – including your home – are divided by the court. However, spouses can come to their own agreements about what they consider fair, and courts generally approve these if they appear equitable and voluntary.
Jurisdictional notes:
- Most states, including Virginia, South Carolina, and Florida, follow equitable distribution laws that focus on fairness over a strict 50/50 split.
- Texas is a community property state, and property division generally begins with a 50/50 presumption, then considers other factors to ensure fairness.
What Assets Get Divided in a Divorce?
A home may be the most significant asset in a marriage, but it isn’t the only one. Courts look at the entire marital estate when dividing assets (and debts) to ensure fairness. These include:
- Real estate: Primary residences, vacation homes, and investment properties
- Financial assets: Bank accounts, stocks, bonds, and retirement savings
- Personal property: Vehicles, furniture, jewelry, and valuable collections
- Business interests: Ownership shares, family businesses, or professional practices
- Debts: Mortgages, loans, and credit card balances
When dividing the marital estate, some assets may be used to offset others. For example, one spouse may keep the home while the other keeps an equivalent share of retirement savings.
Click to contact our family lawyers today
Is Your House Considered Marital Property?
Not every home is automatically considered a marital asset. Whether your home will be divided as marital property will depend on a few things:
- Was it purchased during the marriage? A home purchased after the wedding is usually considered marital property, regardless of whose name is on the deed.
- Was it owned by one spouse before the marriage? A home owned by one spouse before the marriage may remain separate property (not subject to division), but only if marital funds weren’t used to pay the mortgage, make improvements, or cover taxes.
- Were funds commingled? If marital funds, shared income, or funds from a joint account were used to pay expenses for the home, this can turn part of a separate property home into a marital asset.
- Did it increase in value during the marriage? Even if one spouse owned the home before the marriage, if it has appreciated in value due to both spouses’ efforts or financial input, that increased value may be considered marital.
- Was the home gifted or inherited? A home received as a personal gift or inheritance is typically considered separate property, unless it was treated as a shared marital home or its equity was mixed with joint assets.
In other words, whether your home is divisible marital property or not will depend on timing, ownership, and financial intermingling. The clearer your records, the easier it will be to prove what portion belongs to you.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today
Options for Dividing the House After Divorce
The marital home can be an emotionally and financially significant asset during a divorce. It often represents years of shared investments and memories, especially when children are involved. At the same time, it also is a major financial asset that may be tied up in equity, debt, and future obligations.
Deciding what to do with it requires balancing practical and financial realities with personal priorities. For some spouses, keeping the home means continuity and comfort, whereas for others, selling it allows a clean financial break and freedom to create a new life.
The following are the three most common remedies to dividing the marital home, each with advantages and challenges. How you and your spouse handle dividing the house will depend on factors such as your finances, your ability to refinance independently, the continuity and stability of your children, and your long-term goals.
Selling the marital home and dividing the proceeds
Selling the home is often the most straightforward option. Once the home sells, the mortgage and any related debts are paid off, and the remaining proceeds are divided between spouses, either equally or according to an agreed-upon amount. Selling can simplify the process and eliminate ongoing joint financial obligations. It also allows both parties to start fresh, although it can be emotionally difficult when the home holds sentimental value.
One spouse buys out the other’s share
In this option, one spouse keeps the home and compensates the other for their share of the equity, either through a lump-sum payment, a refinance, or offsetting it with other assets, such as retirement funds or investments. This arrangement is common when one spouse wants to maintain stability for the children. However, it typically requires that the spouse keeping the home has sufficient income and credit to refinance it and manage a mortgage independently.
Spouses exchange property or assets instead of cash
Sometimes, one spouse may retain the marital home while the other receives other assets of comparable value, such as a larger share of savings, investments, or retirement accounts. This approach can simplify the division process and help balance equity without requiring large cash transfers. However, if a mortgage remains on the property, the home must still be refinanced into the retaining spouse’s name to ensure both the loan and the title reflect sole ownership. Without this step, the spouse who moves out may remain financially liable, which can complicate future credit or home purchases.
If spouses can’t reach an agreement on what to do with the home, the court will intervene and determine the fairest solution based on financial circumstances, each party’s earning capacity, and the overall division of assets. In some cases, judges order the sale of the property to ensure both parties receive their equitable share of the value.
What Do Courts Consider When Determining Who Gets the House After Divorce
When couples can’t reach an agreement about who should keep the marital home or how its value should be divided, the court will step in to make that decision.
Judges don’t rely on emotions in these decisions; they apply specific legal and equitable factors established by state law. These factors are designed to create fairness, taking into account both spouses’ financial circumstances and contributions to the marriage. However, this process can feel extremely personal when it involves shared memories, sacrifices, and sentimental value.
While each case is unique, the court’s primary goal is fairness, and many factors are considered to ensure this is achieved with the division of the marital home. These factors include:
- The length of the marriage – Longer marriages tend to result in more shared assets and financial interdependence. Courts often lean more toward dividing property more evenly when both spouses contributed significantly over time.
- Income and future earning potential – Judges look at each spouse’s current income and future earning capacity. A spouse with limited earning ability or who sacrificed career opportunities for family responsibilities may receive a larger portion of the marital estate, in some cases.
- Contributions to the marriage – Both financial and non-financial efforts matter when the court is making these decisions. While one spouse may have earned the majority of the income, the other’s role in raising children, managing the home, or supporting the other’s career is also recognized as a valuable contribution.
- Debts and liabilities – Courts also consider marital debt when making property division decisions. Mortgages, loans, credit card balances, and other marital debts are balanced against assets to ensure one spouse isn’t unfairly burdened. The spouse retaining the home may also take on the associated mortgage debt.
- Children’s needs and custody arrangements – When minor children are involved, maintaining stability for them is typically an essential factor in who gets the house. Judges may allow the custodial parent to remain in the home temporarily to provide continuity in their schooling and community ties.
- Age and health of the spouses – A spouse in poor health or nearing retirement age may be given greater consideration if maintaining housing stability is vital to their well-being.
- Tax implications – Property division can have significant tax consequences. Courts and divorce attorneys often weigh how transferring or selling the home will affect each party’s tax liability before finalizing a decision.
- Marital misconduct – Even in no-fault divorce situations, marital misconduct is sometimes considered by the court in property division decisions, especially if the misconduct directly impacted the marital finances.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Marital Home in Divorce
1. Can I keep the house after divorce if my spouse’s name is on the mortgage?
Yes, but only under specific conditions. If you want to keep the home and your spouse’s name is still on the mortgage, you’ll likely need to refinance the loan into your name alone. This process removes your spouse’s financial liability and ensures the property title matches current ownership. Refinancing also demonstrates to the court and your lender that you have the financial ability to maintain the home on your own. If refinancing isn’t possible, selling the house or negotiating an alternative arrangement may be necessary.
2. What if my spouse owned the home before we got married?
A home purchased before marriage is generally considered separate property, but that can change depending on how it was used and paid for during the marriage. If marital funds were used for mortgage payments, renovations, or property taxes, or if both spouses contributed to maintaining or improving the home, part of its equity may be classified as marital property. In those cases, both spouses could be entitled to a share of its value, even if only one name appears on the original deed.
3. Does it matter who moves out of the marital home during divorce?
Moving out doesn’t automatically mean you lose your rights to the home. However, it can affect temporary custody or possession orders, especially if children are involved. Courts generally look at who continues to maintain the property and whether leaving the home was voluntary or necessary (for example, due to safety or conflict concerns). Before making a decision to move out, it’s best to speak with an attorney to understand how it may impact your financial or legal position during the divorce process.
Who Gets the House? Protecting Your Home, Your Finances, and Your Future
For most families, the marital house represents far more than an asset. It is the backdrop of their shared story. Yet when a marriage ends, that same house becomes one of the most complex pieces of the divorce process. Deciding who gets the house – and whether to keep it, sell it, or divide its value – touches on nearly every issue in family law: financial stability, parenting, fairness, and emotional well-being.
Throughout this process, it’s important to remember that every decision about the house is also a decision about the future. A choice that feels emotionally satisfying might not be legally or financially sound. Understanding how the division of your home will impact you in the future and how your state weighs its decisions can help you make informed decisions that consider both your short-term stability and your long-term security. That being said, the best outcomes typically happen when both spouses can work together toward a fair resolution.
Divorce laws may differ, and financial realities change, but the need to protect your home and stability remains the same. At Melone Hatley, P.C., our experienced divorce attorneys can help you navigate every stage of the divorce process, from property division and financial considerations to custody and support. Whether through negotiation or litigation, we are dedicated to helping you protect what matters most. Call us at 1-800-479-8124 or contact us through our website to schedule a free consultation with one of our Client Services Coordinators.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today.
